Consultancy · Independent investigation

An allegation against staff or a volunteer.

Somebody has raised a concern about a member of staff or a volunteer. Your organisation has to establish what happened, fairly, and be able to stand over how it did so. Michael carries out that investigation from outside the organisation.

Talk to Michael in confidence

Before anything else

Reporting comes first, always.

If a child may be at risk, the concern goes to Tusla, and to An Garda Síochána where required, before anything else happens. An independent investigation never replaces that report, and it should never delay it.

Michael will ask what the statutory agencies have been told before any work is agreed.

What the Act asks of you

Your statement already promises a procedure.

Under the Children First Act 2015, your child safeguarding statement must set out procedures for any member of staff under investigation.

Under the Act, member of staff includes anyone your organisation permits to work on its behalf, paid or not. Volunteers are covered.

How it is done

Terms agreed first, findings last.

01

Terms of reference

Agreed in writing before anything begins: the allegation, the questions to be answered, and who receives the report.

02

Fair procedures

The person concerned is told what is alleged and has a fair opportunity to respond before any finding is made.

03

Interviews and records

The people who can say what happened, and the records that show it, each interview noted in writing.

04

A written report

A finding on each question in the terms of reference, the evidence for it, and what the organisation should consider next.

Why independent

A colleague investigating a colleague convinces nobody.

Whatever an internal investigation finds, somebody will doubt it. The person accused, the family and the board all need a finding from someone with no stake in the answer.

Michael spent fifteen years leading investigations whose findings had to survive scrutiny.

Michael Lynch

Who you would be working with

Fifteen years leading Ireland's national child protection unit.

Senior Investigating Officer with An Garda Síochána, leading three national units: the National Child Protection Unit, the Sexual Crime Management Unit and the Online Child Exploitation Unit. Ireland's National Expert to Interpol and Europol on child safeguarding.

Safeguarding policy developed with Tusla, the HSE and three government departments. M.Sc. in Child Protection and Welfare, Trinity College Dublin. More about Michael

do what you love, safely

Organisations Michael has worked with

TuslaTusla
HSEHSE
United NationsUnited Nations
InterpolInterpol
European CommissionEuropean Commission
GAAGAA
Scouting IrelandScouting Ireland
Teaching CouncilTeaching Council
Dublin Rape Crisis CentreDublin Rape Crisis Centre
CARICARI
Irish Red CrossIrish Red Cross
DSPCADSPCA
St John AmbulanceSt John Ambulance
UCDUCD
Trinity College DublinTrinity College Dublin
ERA — Academy of European LawERA — Academy of European Law

Answers

Questions people ask at this point.

Something has just been reported. What do we do first?

Report to Tusla, and to An Garda Síochána where required, under your own procedures. An investigation by the organisation comes after that, never instead of it.

Do we suspend the person while it is investigated?

Suspension under an allegations procedure is without prejudice and makes no finding about guilt. Whether it is needed depends on the risk to the child concerned and to other children. The decision is the organisation's.

What if the allegation is about our DLP or a manager?

Then it does not go through them. Your procedures should say who receives it instead, usually the chair or the board.

Who receives the report?

Whoever the terms of reference name, usually the board or the chair. The report is yours to act on.

How long does an investigation take?

It depends on how many allegations there are and how many people need to be interviewed. The likely scope is agreed in the terms of reference before work begins.

Related: what to do when a concern arrives, and an independent review of how an incident was handled.

The first conversation

Thirty minutes. No cost.

Tell Michael, in general terms and without names, what has been alleged and where things stand. He will tell you whether an independent investigation is what you need.

  • Whether Tusla and the Gardaí have been told
  • What the terms of reference should cover
  • What it would cost, and how long it would take

Book a free 30-minute call